Breakfast Menu "The Sub & Pizza" Amherst
Neighborhood mainstay supplying sandwiches, pies & other pizzeria-style finger foods.
The Sub & Pizza, 33 E Pleasant St, Amherst, MA 01002
Photos
All
Vibe
Street View & 360°
Services
Service options
Accessibility
Offerings
Planning
Payments
Children
User Reviews
$3.00 for a slice of pizza that is nearly a quarter of a pizza? hell yes. This was the place my friends and I went after we hit up the bars. Despite us and many others being drunk the staff were efficient and polite. I'm very sad this places *seems* to have shut down. Even when I was 1,500 miles away from home over the summer all I wanted was pizza from the Sub & Pizza. The chicken bacon ranch pizza was unparalleled. The only down side of this place was that it wasn't exceptionally furnished and updated but- the food was wonderful.
Ordered a ham sandwich, 2 chocolate chip cookies and 1 macadamia nut cookie. I received a call shortly after stating they only had 2 macadamia nut cookies left and they would bring me my refund for the 3rd cookie. CONS: * I waited over an hour on a Monday night for a ham sandwich and 2 cookies. * The cookies were as hard as a rock; almost like its been sitting out for more than a few days and one cookies was so small it was almost non-existent. * There was only a very thin layer of meat on this sandwich; not worth $ 7.50 PROS: * They were polite. * Food was fresh. * Sandwich tasted decent. * I got my .85 cents back for the 3rd cookie I didn't get.
Pepperoni and crispy chicken pizza. Sound odd? I ate that stuff regularly my last two years in Amherst. Incredible stuff. I know Antonio's is the favorite around there, but I'll always be in Sub & Pizza's corner. They have the best pizza in Amherst, in my opinion.
I should have been a little suspicious when I realized I was the only one in this restaurant on June 19th 2014 at 5:30 pm. Ordered a sausage parmigianna sub. Unwrapped it when I got home. Found something else entirely with chicken and drippy catsup/mustard and pickels. Paid 10 dollars. I know people make mistakes but when you're the only customer in the restaurant and there are three employees behind the counter, it seems like they should get it right. Too far away to go back so I tossed it. I would not go there again.
Good food. As someone who worked there I can say they keep a very clean kitchen! Delivery can be slow Thursday - Saturday if you order after 8:30 due to the number of orders. Try the chicken taco pizza and fried dough bites!
The pizza here showed up cold and made my friends and I sick, I called to let them know and was accused of being drunk when I was sober and had a very rude interaction with the staff. Would absolutely never recommend pizza from Sub and Pizza.
Rude staff. Average food at best. Takes advantage of local colleges by staying open late. Good deal of free pizza with two large subs purchase.
New management - pretty good so far! Good portion, fair price, tasty food. And they actually deliver! Not Little Italy but good stuff nonetheless.