Breakfast Menu "Nina's Italian Grill" Sherburne

Nina's Italian Grill, 93 N Main St, Sherburne, NY 13460

(607) 674-9055

About Nina's Italian Grill Restaurant

Ratings: 4 stars based on 19 reviews

Opening Hours

Thursday: 11 AM–10 PM

Friday: 11 AM–10 PM

Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM

Sunday: 11 AM–10 PM

Monday: 11 AM–10 PM

Tuesday: 11 AM–10 PM

Wednesday: 11 AM–10 PM

Photos

Services

Service options

Outdoor seating, Dine-in, Delivery

Highlights

Great beer selection, Great cocktails, Great dessert

Popular for

Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible restroom

Offerings

Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Coffee, Comfort food, Hard liquor, Quick bite, Vegetarian options, Wine

Dining options

Lunch, Dinner, Dessert

Amenities

Bar onsite, Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual, Cozy, Quiet

Crowd

Groups, Tourists

Planning

Accepts reservations

Payments

Credit cards, Debit cards

Children

Good for kids, High chairs, Kids' menu

User Reviews

I did not eat here. I was looking for a quick sandwich or sub to go. The attractive ladies there showed me a menu and I declined. I ended up at Subway doen the street. The place looked charming both inside and out. The picture on Google is old because the lighthouse has been painted red.

Half Classy, Full Function On first glance, the outside of Nina's may not be entirely impressive. But if you are looking for decent food and have a few extra pennies in your pocket, it's well worth your time. There are three rooms upon entry through the main doors. A bar room to the left, (which currently serves no alcohol, but welcomes patrons to bring their own) and a large, somewhat tight main dining room to the right, with a seating and pick-up hub at the center. The decor is freshly remodeled and comfortable, faux stone and dark red paint accented with soft lighting and black furniture. Our waitstaff was young and friendly, although visibly fresh. The appeal of younger women can falter when they struggle with their jobs, but this did not seem like the case with our waitress. Their only difficulty seemed to be moving around the cramped dining area. The food is fairly standard, although slightly pricey for the area. Motzarella sticks were your average batch, served melted and warm. (as they should be) When ordering salads, inquire on the dressing. We asked for italian and were given an oil infusion that, while tastey and possibly my new favorite, was not quite accurate. The bread is absolutely fantastic, and this is coming from someone who can take or leave it in most circumstances. We ordered a mushroom steak entrée to split and the result could have been better. Ordering a medium steak gave us a slightly charred piece of steak completely slathered in mushroom sauce. For someone with an affinity for gravy, however, it wasn't much of a problem. It is worth noting that Nina's also serves tremendous pizza, of which I have had on a separate occasion. This seems to be their claim to fame, so it may be a better place to start.

Our dinner last night was excellent! The Prime Rib was delicious and our waitress, Christina was the best! Thanks Christina for your excellent service.

The service was terrible/ We had a group of 12 and half ordered the buffet. The buffet was not ready when we arrived at 11:30/ the food was OK, but nothing to rave about. WE will not book there again

Called to order a chicken salad,asked if we could get it baked instead of marinated.The guy was extremely rude and gave me attitude.Who doesn't deliver on a Saturday? Probably wont be brining my business here again!

Amazingly bad service last night. Our group was ignored for so long that almost everyone left without even getting drinks and many vowed never to come back.

Inside is rather dull, parking can be inconvenient if it's a busy time. Food is good and reasonably priced.

We always enjoy. The food .. too die for.. and We enjoy the company! ! Jeanette and Scott are absolutely positively awesome. ! ! !