Breakfast Menu "Lenny's Bagels" Rye Brook
Longtime, casual outpost featuring housemade bagels, breakfast/lunch sandwiches, salads & coffee.
Lenny's Bagels, 172 S Ridge St, Rye Brook, NY 10573
Photos
All
Menu
Food & drink
Vibe
Take-out
Display case
Street View & 360°
Services
Service options
Accessibility
Dining options
Planning
Payments
User Reviews
Hot sandwich’s are good and I come here on occasion, today I went asked for a dozen onion bagels and they only had 7. The lady told me to ask my mother if garlic is fine (I was by myself). I have never met this woman before and don’t understand why she would say something like this to a customer when I asked for something. She insisted on giving me an assorted dozen. Won’t be coming back.
You can tell them 100 times no onions on the egg omelette and they will still put it in - that’s just the way they are - just accept it and move on - they didn’t want to give us a drink even though the combo says drink is included - they say it’s only hot but not cold, yet they will give us a glass of ice for the tea???? Just does not make sense. Everyone including my friends n neighbors complain about this place but they still come / don’t get why
I use to love this place. Over the past years, portions have gotten smaller. Bagel prices have increased. I’ve stopped frequenting this place daily and starting going monthly. If you want a good bagel that’s a bit over priced, this is the place for you. Pictured is the egg bagel with egg whites, spinach, and turkey bacon. As you can see there’s barely much of a sandwich there. Disappointed in the downhill progression.
If you can’t trust a local bagel store to have fresh bagels on a Sunday morning, what can you trust in life? First few times I went here everything was great. But today it was incredibly disappointing. All I did was order 8 bagels at 9:30am on a Sunday morning. And every single bagel was stale. So stale that I nearly sliced my finger trying to cut them with a serrated knife! And on top of that they were terribly rolled.
Local staple. Reviews shouldn’t be allowed for this gem. I’ve been going here for 13 years and I do admit the quality has dropped a tiny bit but I think that’s due to the surge in online ordering post Covid combined with them being short staffed. The bagels are still the best outside of NYC/Long Island and the breakfast sandwiches are delicious.
I go to Lenny’s every week. I finally decided to order in today and this is what the delivery guy had the audacity to hand me. Cups of soup with the lids smashed and literally dripping wet bagels. He said his pants were wet too and there’s nothing he could do about it. Utterly shocked at this poor service. Thank you for ruining the first day of 2022.
Best bagel I've had north of New York City. Everything you order at Lenny's tastes killer, and you can get it for a great value. I also feel the staff takes care of their customers really well, which I appreciate.
Dude 2 coffee and 1 drink and a bacon egg and cheese on a bagle is 27 dollars? 15-17 is what I normally pay. You are over priced.