Breakfast Menu "Jersey Boardwalk Pizza" Tavernier

We called ahead. 33 Bucks later we picked our food up. Garlic cheese bread, medium pepperoni pizza, steak & cheese with french fries. First the fries would have been great if they were cooked fresh. We get to the car and they're all limp and warm. Moving on to the garlic bread, it's okay a little dry even with the cheese, good garlic chunks. Opened the pizza box and it looked and tasted as it was reheated. It didn't have any sauce on it. The picture on the left hand side is a piece I took the cheese off. Nope didn't have a taste at all to it. Then quickly moved onto the steak and cheese. And we love our steak and cheeses but this one tastes more like a hot roast beef and cheese on a soggy bun. Totally disappointing, high hopes crushed. Nice looking place besides the black hole where your order comes thru after you pay.

The service is very fast and the pizza is huge, the folks working there are kind. The pizza was okay: good when compared to the american standard, but far from the real Italian pizza. Last year the quality of the ingredients was superior, 4 star, so this year I give 3 stars.

Food is delicious. Had a medium pizza (8 slices) with onions and mushrooms, chicken fingers, and a Philly Cheese steak with fries. Not the best pizza I have ever had, but it was very good. Perfect cheese / sauce balance, not salty but very tasty, and crust was thin and crunchy. Wasn't greasy either. Philly was very tasty, meat was tender and not over cooked, hogie wasn't real thick. Chicken fingers was a good portion , 5 fingers, and yummy! Dog friendly, sat outside patio with the little for baby. Solid place, will return for sure!

We stopped by to get a med sized pizza(sausage, black olive and mushroom) and it was very good. Friendly and fast service. The pizza crust is on the thinner side and is very crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. We plan on going back for seconds!

It was okay. Service was mediocre. Lady was decent but not very friendly. Prices were okay unless you got the calzone which is WAY overpriced. $9.99 for cheese... $1.75 for each additional topping. Had the cheesesteak which was decent and pretty reasonably priced at $8.90 which had all of the toppings (peppers, onions, mushrooms) . Would probably get something else next time. Will try it again but only if I'm craving pizza.

Not completely authentic but close enough. Seems like a popular place and I felt relieved that there were a few free tables inside when we walked in (hot day -- really wanted the AC). Service was competent (tho our server clearly had a two digit IQ). The pizza was slightly thicker crust than I'm used to (you know, in jersey) but was still good. Don't know if I've ever been to a jersey pizza joint that didn't have Snapple. Well, this place didn't, which is probably a Snapple distribution issue out of their control. Although there was beer in the refrigerator I ended up drinking some sugary soft drink. Anyway, I'd go back.

Great pizza and great service! The waitress was very responsive and they even watch each others tables to keep things moving when the one waitress got a table of 15. My kids love the food and stated best pizza in the keys!

Very disappointed. my husband and I practically grew up in the keys and recently purchased in Tavernier a place of our own. We had been wanting to visit Jersey Boardwalk for some time. Finally we came for,dinner with the kids and although the pizza was great, and our server was super nice, there was an extremely RUDE older waitress/lady , I'm guessing manager or even owner wearing swirly tortoise prescription glasses, (because she was ordering all the waiters around while they were attending other tables) that needs to retire and stay home. My husband and I sat in one table and the kids behind us because we all didn't fit. I knew from the moment our waiter was speaking to us and she rudely interrupted by telling him to go outside because there was a party of 12 she didn't like us for some reason! She brought my kids pizza to our table and I told her it wasn't ours that it was the other table and she practically snatched it away from our table! Then she rudely said to me "and you guys are not eating anything?" Well all of a sudden I see her throwing an order away with an attitude, 15 minutes later our waiter comes to tell me and my husband that my pizza order got lost, they couldn't find it and they had to place the order again! Meanwhile our kids were already finished with their dinner! When we finally finished our pizza, she came to take the tray from our table and again snatched the tray and turns away! I have NEVER been treated that way in any restaurant , and we eat out at East 4 times a week! What a horrible experience! Everyone is always so nice in the Keys! That lady is gonna make this great restaurant loose a lot of business! I can tell you now, that neither me nor my family will EVER set foot in that place again much less recommend it to anyone!! I will gladly continue driving to Tower of Pizza in Key Largo like I have for the past 20+ years! What a shame how one person can ruin such a great thing!!