Breakfast Menu "Irish Coffee Pub" East Islip
Longtime spot for Continental & Irish classics in white-tablecloth setting, plus folk music & patio.
Irish Coffee Pub, 131 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY 11730
Photos
All
Latest
Videos
Menu
Food & drink
Vibe
Guinness
By owner
Street View & 360°
Services
Service options
Highlights
Popular for
Accessibility
Offerings
Dining options
Amenities
Atmosphere
Crowd
Planning
Payments
Children
User Reviews
A family favorite to celebrate holidays and special events, the Irish Coffee Pub never fails to deliver an exceptional meal and outstanding service. My family have been coming here for more than a decade and love the classic ambiance and seasonal menu. I personally absolutely love their potato soup, which is a long-term staple on the menu and the best I've ever had. Meals are a bit expensive but you are paying for quality and a great experience, both of which we have had every time we had eaten here.
10/10 Every time I dine here it's always a really great experience. All the staff are friendly and attentive but the standout that will make me return every time is how high quality the food is.
I've dined here many times over the years and the food and service never disappoints. The menu has variety for everyone, and you can't go wrong with any you order. The service is always top notch, and the piano player adds to the already relaxing and inviting atmosphere. Highly recommended.
What a great place for Mother's day dinner or to celebrate any special occasion. Our server was attentive and helpful with suggestions. The food was spaced beautifully with bread, appetizers, salads, and then the main course. Ample portions and everyone left full. The blackened sea bass was delicious, as were the scallops, salmon and surf and turf, everyone was impressed. Thanks so much for a great evening!
It was good, got the Shepard's pie, it was absolutely delicious. The only problem I had was that my friend ordered a burger with caramelized onions. I never checked if we paid for it, and she was ok without them. The burger was great. The waitress was super sensitive to my friends severe food allergies, even mentioned the fries being cooked with shell fish oil.
The Irish Coffee Pub recently hosted my parents 60th anniversary party. From start to finish the level of service and competence was unsurpassed. My mother made initial contact with Steven. At the time of her inquiry she had already unsuccessfully attempted to secure a venue for the event at several establishments. From their first conversation Steven assured her that everything would be taken care of and he went above and beyond to deliver on his promise. My parents were in Florida and were unable to deliver a deposit from that distance. Steven insisted the date was secure and there was nothing to worry about. He advised my mother to review the menu in advance so she was prepared to plan the remainder of the details. When my parents met with Steven he could not have been better. He asked all the right questions and gave my parents great guidance choosing the menu. He asked if there would be children attending, and informed her there would be a kids menu available for them at no additional charge. After the menu was completed my mother had concerns about one of her choices. Steven made the change to the menu without hesitation. He did a great job of recommending seating arrangements based on the number of guests and the layout of the room. When the day of the party arrived Patrick oversaw the event. Patrick continued Stevens excellent level of service throughout the day. Everything was absolutely perfect. Every request was met without issue and Patrick and the staff were happy to accommodate. The staff was absolutely perfect. From the servers to the bartender everyone was professional, accommodating, and genuinely contributed to making the special event a wonderful experience for my parents. It obviously goes without saying that I highly recommend the Irish Coffee Pub for any event. Their level of service absolutely can not be matched for any event that you may plan.
Just had my daughter's bridal shower in the Tara Room. The food was delicious, so much food, I could hardly finish. The service was fantastic and the room was just so pretty. Our servers were attentive at all times and were always on hand to help. Everything went smoothly. Thank you so much!!
Stopped at the Irish Coffee Pub to have , what else, A Classic Irish Coffee and a slice of cake. Delicious. Host was so gracious. Talkative and informative and inviting. Very cozy place. Packed. Old school place. If you like piano music, comfort food and great company, stop by for dinner or dessert. I'm glad we did. Will be back for dinner for sure.