Breakfast Menu "Gettysburg Eddie's" Gettysburg
Casual American restaurant & sports bar dedicated to local baseball Hall of Famer Edward Plank.
Gettysburg Eddie's, 217 Steinwehr Ave, Gettysburg, PA 17325
Photos
All
Latest
Videos
Menu
Food & drink
Vibe
Take-out
Fish and chips
Clam chowder
Chicken sandwich
Chicken Wings
By owner
Street View & 360°
Services
Service options
Highlights
Popular for
Accessibility
Offerings
Dining options
Amenities
Atmosphere
Crowd
Payments
Children
User Reviews
This is our third trip to Gettysburg and FINALLY we found a place to eat that checks all the boxes! Great food, service, and atmosphere. The food was delicious and our server was pleasant and attentive! We got there before the dinner rush so our experience was quick too! We didn't have to wait long for anything. Definitely recommend and will return!
Shrimp & crab bisque was a little salty, but still really good! We liked that it had little shrimp and other bits in the soup. The salmon with lemon dill drizzle was perfectly cooked! He added the crab dip the the cheeseburger, a fantastic combination. The burger was cooked exactly the way he asked, also very good! We were sat upstairs which is a bit of a tight fit. Our 2 top table was a bit small and pretty close to the tables around us, but we made it work. Small bathrooms. Overall, good experience!
We were referred to this restaurant by a friend. It was crowded, but they were able to seat us quickly. Our server was really nice, and she made sure we had what we needed. We ordered Philly Cheesesteak sandwiches. They were delicious! If you love baseball, you will love the atmosphere here. Definitely go here if you are in the area.
Great environment. Great service. Good food. Awesome beer choices. I've lived beside Gettysburg my entire life but had never been here til this past weekend. We ended up getting the Philly cheese steak and the black and blue burger with grilled onions and bacon. Both meals were sensational and HUGE. We'll be back!
This was my first time ever eating here, inside the restaurant was really nice and I really enjoyed the baseball theme. The food was all mainly good with the cheesecake and fries being the best. I would definitely order both of those again. I got the chicken tenders and they were really good except they had some hard and chewy pieces I couldn’t eat and ending up resulting in about 1 tender worth of inedible bites, but it did come with 5 total. My bf got the firecracker shrimp tacos and did enjoy those. However I got the Mac and cheese and I did not enjoy that at all. It had hardly any flavor and I could only eat a few bites after drowning it in salt and pepper and even then I only took a few bites because I didn’t enjoy it much. I would come here again for a few things I ate but definitely not the mac and cheese or possibly the tenders. Also not sure if they have somewhere to park bc I couldn’t see a place and ended up having to use a meter, which coming from Florida where I never even see meters where I live, it was weird but only $2 for 2 hours so not bad.
Amazing Philly cheesesteak with homemade cheese sauce. Fries are so crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Buffalo chicken quesadilla is CHOCK full of chicken. Their house made ranch is outstanding as well. We had Terry as our server and he was so kind and attentive despite the busyness! Our glasses were never empty. Cool atmosphere too! Definitely stop by this one!
This place was great! Tried a new hard cider and it was delicious. The cream dip I added to my burger, I would skip on next time. It might be good with the pretzel, it was just a lot of cream cheese for me. The parking is in the back but it was kind of difficult to find never having been there before. Definitely recommend trying!
Philly cheesesteaks were great and the kids options had nice size portions. Cool atmosphere and would eat here again.