Breakfast Menu "Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream" Bay Shore
Photos
All
Menu
Videos
Food & drink
Vibe
Street View & 360°
Services
Service options
Accessibility
Dining options
Crowd
Planning
Payments
User Reviews
It’s an incredible ice cream place and it left me in awe! With an impressive selection of 60 homemade flavors and a wide range of toppings, it's a true paradise for ice cream lovers. The friendly atmosphere and the heartwarming display of pictures showcasing happy customers added to the overall charm. I give it a perfect 10/10 for the taste, and I'm already planning my next visit to explore even more delightful flavors. Can't wait to be back!
Great ice cream! Great service! So many flavor options!
This used to be our favorite ice cream spot, we would go here almost every week in the summer and twice a month in the cooler months. We’d get birthday cakes and bring friends and family here. Things have changed. Twice I’ve gone and asked for large cups of ice cream and received a large cup with the ice cream BARELY reaching the top rim of the cup. I wouldn’t mind paying a little more if post COVID times are difficult on your business but I do have an issue with your current practices. Shame on you Coyles I thought better of you.
We brought our special needs middle school students from RMMS in North Babylon on a field trip to COYLES, where they opened early to accommodate us. The staff was patient while the students ordered and paid for their ice cream. We would absolutely go back again and are planning on it!!
Hubby and I decided to try this spot on a whim before traveling home after a long summer day at the outlet. Wow. Just amazing. They don't hold back with the toppings, and the ice cream is sooo wholesome and dangerously good. I couldn't finish the whole thing and so I put the remainder in the freezer when I got home. I pulled it out the next day and it still tasted A-Mazzzzzz-ing! Lol
Nice place. Super tasty. The stuff is attentive . Heaven of ice cream
Homemade, fresh, and such a nostalgic ice cream shop feel here! Kathy the owner is amazing!
I love this place! Homemade ice cream. Many amazing flavors to choose from. They have soft served ice cream as well. There are weekly specials for different days of the week like; discounted root beer floats, banana splits, sundaes, I'm not sure which days are which but you can call ahead or there's a sign up when you go. Service was lovely. They let you mix and match flavors They also sell homemade ice cream cakes and ice cream sandwiches which I haven't gotten to try yet but they look amazing.