Breakfast Menu "Anthony's Pizzeria" East Rockaway
Photos
All
Menu
Food & drink
Vibe
Take-out
Pasta
Lasagna
Pizza
By owner
Street View & 360°
Services
Service options
Popular for
Accessibility
Offerings
Dining options
Atmosphere
Crowd
Planning
Payments
Children
User Reviews
First time walking in, ordered a Regular slice and sausage slice (which I haven't had in a while). Very Thin dough , no burnt edges. The cheese was predominat without the grease. The sausage slice, same. No Heavy grease thin dough great cheese. Would like to come in for a burger Next.
Edgar is the best and knows his pizza, we love the mild wings and recently got hooked on The Boss pizza.
We have been eating at Anthony's for a couple of years now and love the food. They're heros are excellent. Their rolls and pinwheels are fantastic. Entrees are well portioned. Their sauce is yummy. Their meat lovers pizza is to die for. Even just their plain cheese pie is delicious. My family loves Anthony's Pizzeria and this is our go to place for quick, inexpensive and delicious Italian food.
Always delicious pizza! I work a few minutes up the road and anytime my girls want pizza Anthony’s us always are go to! The pizza is always delicious and made perfectly every time!
great marinara sauce is first off, fresh in an understatement ! I also had the chicken parm I believe and it was delicious perfect through every bite 🙏🏾 . customer service goes right in with the food 5 stars . favorite place in western Long Island
Just ordered garlic knots and had to return them. Watered down sauce, garlic burnt, ends of the knots tough as nails. Yet the owner manager girl states they are PERFECT!!! An unfortunate nasty experience all around :-( If you are craving REAL garlic knots and not something that resembles "Pilsbury pop and fresh mini croissants" slathered in burnt garlic oil - drive up or walk up to Vincent's in Lynbrook 4/$1.10 which are by the way gigantic knots made just the right amount of garlic and butter (at least to me- you may think otherwise) than 6/$1.50 at Anthony's in E. Rockaway. Should of taken a pic of Anthony's garlic knots but I choose not do. Girl that runs Anthony's is very young and arrogant. How dare her tell some one who has eaten Italian all of his life that I do not know what I am talking about. Growing up I had an Italian American step-mother (she spent 12 hours making xmas eve dinner)
I've dined here and ordered out several times since being introduced to Anthony's and I have never been disappointed in the food, the service, or the staff. I highly recommend Anthony's Pizzeria to anyone in the area - even if you're just passing through.
Good pizza. Edgar is always pleasant and a very nice guy. It gets really busy during summer afternoons but manageable.